Skip to main content

Nixon Peabody LLP

  • People
  • Capabilities
  • Insights
  • About
Trending Topics
    • People
    • Capabilities
    • Insights
    • About
    • Locations
    • Events
    • Careers
    • Alumni
    Practices

    View All

    • Affordable Housing
    • Community Development Finance
    • Corporate & Finance
    • Cybersecurity & Privacy
    • Entertainment & Media
    • Environmental
    • Franchising & Distribution
    • Government Investigations & White Collar Defense
    • Healthcare
    • Intellectual Property
    • International Services
    • Labor, Employment, and Benefits
    • Litigation
    • Private Wealth & Advisory
    • Project Finance
    • Public Finance
    • Real Estate
    • Regulatory & Government Relations
    Industries

    View All

    • Aviation
    • Cannabis
    • Consumer
    • Energy
    • Financial Services
    • Healthcare
    • Higher Education
    • Infrastructure
    • Manufacturing
    • Nonprofit Organizations
    • Real Estate
    • Sports & Stadiums
    • Technology
    Value-Added Services

    View All

    • Alternative Fee Arrangements

      Developing innovative pricing structures and alternative fee agreement models that deliver additional value for our clients.

    • Continuing Education

      Advancing professional knowledge and offering credits for attorneys, staff and other professionals.

    • Crisis Advisory

      Helping clients respond correctly when a crisis occurs.

    • DEI Strategic Services

      Providing our clients with legal, strategic, and practical advice to make transformational changes in their organizations.

    • eDiscovery

      Leveraging law and technology to deliver sound solutions.

    • Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG)

      We help clients create positive return on investments in people, products, and the planet.

    • Global Services

      Delivering seamless service through partnerships across the globe.

    • Innovation

      Leveraging leading-edge technology to guide change and create seamless, collaborative experiences for clients and attorneys.

    • IPED

      Industry-leading conferences focused on affordable housing, tax credits, and more.

    • Legal Project Management

      Providing actionable information to support strategic decision-making.

    • Legally Green

      Teaming with clients to advance sustainable projects, mitigate the effects of climate change, and protect our planet.

    • Nixon Peabody Trust Company

      Offering a range of investment management and fiduciary services.

    • NP Capital Connector

      Bringing together companies and investors for tomorrow’s new deals.

    • NP Second Opinion

      Offering fresh insights on cases that are delayed, over budget, or off-target from the desired resolution.

    • NP Trial

      Courtroom-ready lawyers who can resolve disputes early on clients’ terms or prevail at trial before a judge or jury.

    • Social Impact

      Creating positive impact in our communities through increasing equity, access, and opportunity.

    • Women in Dealmaking

      We provide strategic counsel on complex corporate transactions and unite dynamic women in the dealmaking arena.

    1. Home
    2. Insights
    3. Alerts
    4. NY commercial lease update: Court permits drawdown on letter of credit and rejects tenant’s impossibility of performance argument

      Alerts

    Alert / Real Estate

    NY commercial lease update: Court permits drawdown on letter of credit and rejects tenant’s impossibility of performance argument

    Aug 12, 2020

    LinkedInX (Twitter)EmailCopy URL

    By Richard Shore

    Few courts have tested the enforcement of commercial leases and potential defenses tenants may raise in the COVID-19 pandemic era. We discuss the recent decision in Backal Hospitality Group, LLC v. 627 West 42nd Retail LLC, and what it means for commercial tenants and landlords.

    DOWNLOAD

    PDF: NY commercial lease update

    Due to the ongoing moratorium imposed by Governor Andrew Cuomo’s Executive Order on initiation of proceedings relating to nonpayment of rent and eviction (recently extended to September 4, 2020, by Executive Order 202.55), few courts have yet tested the enforcement of commercial leases and potential defenses tenants may raise in the COVID-19 pandemic era. In this context, the recent decision in Backal Hospitality Group, LLC v. 627 West 42nd Retail LLC [1] is of note for such future proceedings.

    In Backal Hospitality, the Plaintiff-Tenant filed an Order to Show Cause seeking a Temporary Restraining Order and Preliminary Injunction preventing the Defendant-Landlord’s drawdown of its $500,000 letter of credit and a determination that Tenant’s surrender of premises (and Tenant’s return and acceptance by Landlord of the keys of the premises) constitutes a termination of the lease and any of Tenant’s ongoing payment obligations.
    Tenant argued that Governor Cuomo’s Executive Order 202.8, which required all non-essential businesses statewide to close in-office personnel functions, prevented Tenant from operating as an event space, and thus rendered it unable to pay future rent. In support for the injunctive relief sought, Tenant argued that it is likely to succeed on the merits since its surrender of the premises, combined with Landlord’s acceptance of the keys, established that Landlord allowed Tenant to terminate the lease without any penalty.

    The court rejected this argument looking to the terms of the lease, which specifically required that “[n]o agreement to accept a surrender of all or any part of the [premises] shall be valid unless in writing and signed by [Landlord]” and in this case Landlord did not accept the surrender by signed writing; instead Landlord responded to Tenant’s attempt at surrender with a letter stating that it “in no way agreed to terminate the [l]ease” and that it reserved all of its rights pursuant to the lease and otherwise. As such, “[d]espite the fact that [tenant] vacated the premises, it was still liable to pay its arrears, as well as other amounts due under the lease, and [landlord] was permitted by the lease to draw down the [Letter of Credit] for this purpose.”

    Tenant also put forward an impossibility of performance argument “that they are likely to succeed on the merits because the [Executive Order 202.8] prohibiting large gatherings of people rendered it impossible for them to perform under the lease.” Landlord argued that “the novel claim of impossibility of performance, which here is only temporary” is unsupported by applicable case law or the lease.

    Interestingly, the court does not speak to the jurisprudence regarding the proposed invocation of impossibility of performance; instead the court once again looked to the terms of the lease, to a provision neither party actually cited, specifically that “[i]f the [rent] shall be or become uncollectible by virtue of … governmental order… Tenant shall enter into such agreement … to permit Landlord to collect the maximum [rent] … during the continuance of such legal rent restriction [that is] legally permissible.” Once the government order restricting rent collection expires, (a) the lease rent “shall become payable under this Lease … for the period following such termination, and (b) Tenant shall pay to Landlord, if legally permissible, an amount equal to (i) the [rent] which would have been paid pursuant to this Lease, but for such rent restriction, less (ii) the [rent] paid by Tenant to Landlord during the period that such rent restriction was in effect.”

    The Court reasoned that the above provision reflects that the lease “contemplated a scenario in which performance of the lease terms by plaintiffs might become prohibited by a governmental order, and agreed that, if such a situation arose, they would reach an agreement regarding the collection of rent at the conclusion of the governmental restriction. Although the parties attempted in vain to negotiate a lease modification, [Tenant] nevertheless attempted to unilaterally terminate the lease in a manner violative of the terms thereof.”

    Conclusion

    Absent government legislation or other intervention, it seems likely that courts will look specifically to the negotiated lease obligations where the COVID-19 pandemic and governmental restrictions prevent a tenant’s business from operating. Additional jurisprudence will be forthcoming in the months and years ahead, but if the decision in Backal Hospitality is any indication, courts may shy away from relying on judicially created or inferred doctrine, and will instead focus on the terms of the particular lease to govern tenant obligations.

    It should be noted, however, that Tenant did not raise many potential arguments that other tenants are and will likely raise in the coming months, including but not limited to frustration of purpose, applicability of its Force Majeure provision (which provision, like most New York commercial leases, did not excuse performance of payment obligations), and/or Real Property Law § 227.

    Still, both tenants and landlords would be wise to closely read the provisions in their leases, and seek experienced counsel to assist in interpreting the applicability of relevant lease provisions (as well as any applicable judicial doctrines) that may be determinative of any commercial lease dispute.


    1. Backal Hospitality Group, LLC v. 627 West 42nd Retail LLC, Index No. 154141/2020 (Sup. Ct. N.Y. Cnty. August 3, 2020) (Freed, J.) [Back to reference]

    Practices

    Real Estate

    Industries

    Real Estate
    The foregoing has been prepared for the general information of clients and friends of the firm. It is not meant to provide legal advice with respect to any specific matter and should not be acted upon without professional counsel. If you have any questions or require any further information regarding these or other related matters, please contact your regular Nixon Peabody LLP representative. This material may be considered advertising under certain rules of professional conduct.

    Subscribe to stay informed of the latest legal news, alerts, and business trends.Subscribe

    • People
    • Capabilities
    • Insights
    • About
    • Locations
    • Events
    • Careers
    • Alumni
    • Cookie Preferences
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms of Use
    • Accessibility Statement
    • Statement of Client Rights
    • Purchase Order Terms & Conditions
    • Nixon Peabody International LLC
    • PAL
    © 2025 Nixon Peabody. All rights reserved