Skip to main content

Nixon Peabody LLP

  • People
  • Capabilities
  • Insights
  • About
Trending Topics
    • People
    • Capabilities
    • Insights
    • About
    • Locations
    • Events
    • Careers
    • Alumni
    Practices

    View All

    • Affordable Housing
    • Community Development Finance
    • Corporate & Finance
    • Cybersecurity & Privacy
    • Entertainment & Media
    • Environmental
    • Franchising & Distribution
    • Government Investigations & White Collar Defense
    • Healthcare
    • Intellectual Property
    • International Services
    • Labor, Employment, and Benefits
    • Litigation
    • Private Wealth & Advisory
    • Project Finance
    • Public Finance
    • Real Estate
    • Regulatory & Government Relations
    Industries

    View All

    • Aviation
    • Cannabis
    • Consumer
    • Energy
    • Financial Services
    • Healthcare
    • Higher Education
    • Infrastructure
    • Manufacturing
    • Nonprofit Organizations
    • Real Estate
    • Sports & Stadiums
    • Technology
    Value-Added Services

    View All

    • Alternative Fee Arrangements

      Developing innovative pricing structures and alternative fee agreement models that deliver additional value for our clients.

    • Continuing Education

      Advancing professional knowledge and offering credits for attorneys, staff and other professionals.

    • Crisis Advisory

      Helping clients respond correctly when a crisis occurs.

    • DEI Strategic Services

      Providing our clients with legal, strategic, and practical advice to make transformational changes in their organizations.

    • eDiscovery

      Leveraging law and technology to deliver sound solutions.

    • Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG)

      We help clients create positive return on investments in people, products, and the planet.

    • Global Services

      Delivering seamless service through partnerships across the globe.

    • Innovation

      Leveraging leading-edge technology to guide change and create seamless, collaborative experiences for clients and attorneys.

    • IPED

      Industry-leading conferences focused on affordable housing, tax credits, and more.

    • Legal Project Management

      Providing actionable information to support strategic decision-making.

    • Legally Green

      Teaming with clients to advance sustainable projects, mitigate the effects of climate change, and protect our planet.

    • Nixon Peabody Trust Company

      Offering a range of investment management and fiduciary services.

    • NP Capital Connector

      Bringing together companies and investors for tomorrow’s new deals.

    • NP Second Opinion

      Offering fresh insights on cases that are delayed, over budget, or off-target from the desired resolution.

    • NP Trial

      Courtroom-ready lawyers who can resolve disputes early on clients’ terms or prevail at trial before a judge or jury.

    • Social Impact

      Creating positive impact in our communities through increasing equity, access, and opportunity.

    • Women in Dealmaking

      We provide strategic counsel on complex corporate transactions and unite dynamic women in the dealmaking arena.

    1. Home
    2. Insights
    3. Alerts
    4. Updated guidance for HUD Rent Comparability Studies takes effect May 1

      Alerts

    Alert / Affordable Housing

    Updated guidance for HUD Rent Comparability Studies takes effect May 1

    April 12, 2023

    LinkedInX (Twitter)EmailCopy URL

    By Nathaniel Cushman

    Owners, managers, purchasers, and developers of projects assisted by HAP contracts should prepare now to account for these new requirements in any upcoming renewal and rent adjustment submissions.

    What’s the impact?

    • This new guidance affects the threshold for the HUD third-party RCS requirement; affects the valuation of non-shelter services and amenities; and adds requirements relating to renewal processing and closing for early terminations.
    • The new requirements impact renewal and rent adjustment submissions made on or after May 1, 2023—submissions already in process or made through April 30, 2023, will be processed under the existing Chapter 9.

    DOWNLOAD

    PDF: Updated guidance for HUD Rent Comparability Studies

    The Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) recently published an updated version of Chapter 9 of the Section 8 Renewal Guide (the Guide). This chapter of the Guide details requirements for any HUD Rent Comparability Study (RCS), whether submitted as part of a request for renewal of a project-based Section 8 HAP contract or as part of a five-year comparability adjustment under a long-term Option 1 or Option 2 contract. This important guidance will affect owners, managers, purchasers, and developers of projects assisted by Housing Assistance Payment (HAP) contracts. Here is a summary of key highlights from the new Chapter 9.

    Second RCS threshold has been updated

    For some requests, HUD requires review of a third-party RCS commissioned by the owner/agent and a third-party RCS commissioned by HUD. In those situations, rents are set at the lesser of the rent conclusion of the RCS commissioned by the owner/agent or 105% of the rent conclusion in the RCS commissioned by HUD.

    Currently, HUD requires a HUD-commissioned RCS when the requested rent for the subject property’s median unit exceeds 140% of the Median Gross Rent by Zip Code Tabulation Area (GRZCTA) for the property’s zip code. HUD publishes the GRZCTA statistic for all zip codes on its website on an annual basis.

    The new Chapter 9 replaces this threshold test. Now, a HUD-commissioned RCS will be required when the requested gross rent for the full property exceeds the hypothetical gross rent if all units were rented at 150% of the Small Area Fair Market Rent (SAFMR).

    Under this new test, the comparison no longer focuses on the project’s median unit; instead, the comparison takes into account the project’s full unit mix. We, therefore, expect that some properties with smaller bedroom sizes—such as elderly properties with studios and/or one-bedroom units—may be subject to the third-party RCS requirement when historically they were not. Conversely, some properties with larger bedroom sizes may not be subject to a third-party RCS when historically they were.

    Non-shelter services and amenities

    The new chapter updates provisions on adjustments for non-shelter services and amenities. These new provisions include guidance for HAP renewals under Chapter 15 rehab transactions with plans for new services.

    The new Chapter 9 draws a distinction between services “included in rent”—those services a tenant may reliably access for no additional charge—and those that are “incidental.” The RCS should include a valuation for non-shelter services, and the Guide in effect, requires an owner to either have a proven track record and commitment to taking all reasonable steps to continue providing the service for the coming five-year period or to have a written agreement with a credible service provider that specifies certain details of the service provision. Applicable services must be listed each year on the project’s Rent Schedule. If services are interrupted or discontinued, HUD plans to track this through a required change to the annual Rent Schedule.

    Where new services are added as part of a Chapter 15 transaction, those services may be included in the RCS subject to HUD approval. The owner’s submission must include detailed information about the services to be introduced, including who will provide the services, which facilities will be used to provide services, and other details. The owner must then implement the proposed services or risk a reduction in HAP rents under the terms of the Chapter 15 addendum.

    This new Chapter 9 also addresses adjustments for Internet access, such as project-wide WiFi. In recent years there has been some confusion about whether an RCS should make an adjustment where tenants are provided with Internet access for no additional fee. This new Chapter 9 confirms that an adjustment should be made based on actual comparable data from the surrounding market area.

    Timing requirements

    The Guide imposes new timing requirements for transactions involving an early termination of an existing HAP renewal in favor of a new renewal.

    For those transactions, if closing occurs more than one hundred and eighty (180) days (approximately six (6) months) after the date of submission, HUD will require a letter from the appraiser confirming that current rents are not lower than in the original study. Also, if closing occurs more than eighteen (18) months after the original submission, the owner must submit a fully updated RCS.

    Process updates

    Process updates both for identifying factual errors in third-party RCS and appealing HUD review of owner’s studies.

    The Guide incorporates updates to the review process for the owner’s RCS and clarifies the process for identifying factual errors in a third-party RCS ordered by HUD. Of note, the draft Chapter 9 released last year stated that an owner could not supply a revised owner-commissioned RCS as part of an appeal. In an apparent response to industry comment on the draft Chapter 9, the final guidance permits the owner to supply a revised owner-commissioned RCS within this process.

    Effective date

    These new requirements are effective for any renewal and rent adjustment submission made on or after May 1, 2023. Therefore, submissions already in process or being made before the end of April 2023 will be processed under the existing Chapter 9. All other upcoming submissions must account for these new requirements.

    Practices

    Affordable HousingLow Income Housing Tax CreditsSenior Housing & CareSupportive HousingReal EstateSustainable Development

    Industries

    Real Estate

    Insights And Happenings

    • Alert

      HUD enters new era of physical inspections with the NSPIRE Program

      Oct 6, 2023
    • Alert

      New Jersey passes Flood Risk Notification Law

      July 26, 2023
    • Video

      What property owners should know about HUD's new green program

      Affordable Housing
      June 30, 2023
    The foregoing has been prepared for the general information of clients and friends of the firm. It is not meant to provide legal advice with respect to any specific matter and should not be acted upon without professional counsel. If you have any questions or require any further information regarding these or other related matters, please contact your regular Nixon Peabody LLP representative. This material may be considered advertising under certain rules of professional conduct.

    Subscribe to stay informed of the latest legal news, alerts, and business trends.Subscribe

    • People
    • Capabilities
    • Insights
    • About
    • Locations
    • Events
    • Careers
    • Alumni
    • Cookie Preferences
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms of Use
    • Accessibility Statement
    • Statement of Client Rights
    • Purchase Order Terms & Conditions
    • Nixon Peabody International LLC
    • PAL
    © 2025 Nixon Peabody. All rights reserved