Nixon Peabody LLP

  • People
  • Capabilities
  • Insights
  • About

Trending Topics

    • People
    • Capabilities
    • Insights
    • About
    • Locations
    • Events
    • Careers
    • Alumni

    Practices

    View All

    • Affordable Housing
    • Community Development Finance
    • Corporate & Finance
    • Cybersecurity & Privacy
    • Environmental
    • Franchising & Distribution
    • Government Investigations & White Collar Defense
    • Healthcare
    • Intellectual Property
    • International Services
    • Labor & Employment
    • Litigation
    • Private Wealth & Advisory
    • Project Finance
    • Public Finance
    • Real Estate
    • Regulatory & Government Relations

    Industries

    View All

    • Cannabis
    • Consumer
    • Energy
    • Entertainment
    • Financial Services
    • Healthcare
    • Higher Education
    • Infrastructure
    • Manufacturing
    • Non Profit
    • Real Estate
    • Technology

    Value-Added Services

    View All

    • Alternative Fee Arrangements

      Developing innovative pricing structures and alternative fee agreement models that deliver additional value for our clients.

    • Continuing Education

      Advancing professional knowledge and offering credits for attorneys, staff and other professionals.

    • Crisis Advisory

      Helping clients respond correctly when a crisis occurs.

    • DEI Strategic Services

      Providing our clients with legal, strategic, and practical advice to make transformational changes in their organizations.

    • eDiscovery

      Leveraging law and technology to deliver sound solutions.

    • Global Services

      Delivering seamless service through partnerships across the globe.

    • Innovation

      Leveraging leading-edge technology to guide change and create seamless, collaborative experiences for clients and attorneys.

    • IPED

      Industry-leading conferences focused on affordable housing, tax credits, and more.

    • Legal Project Management

      Providing actionable information to support strategic decision-making.

    • Legally Green

      Teaming with clients to advance sustainable projects, mitigate the effects of climate change, and protect our planet.

    • Nixon Peabody Trust Company

      Offering a range of investment management and fiduciary services.

    • NP Capital Connector

      Bringing together companies and investors for tomorrow’s new deals.

    • NP Second Opinion

      Offering fresh insights on cases that are delayed, over budget, or off-target from the desired resolution.

    • NP Trial

      Courtroom-ready lawyers who can resolve disputes early on clients’ terms or prevail at trial before a judge or jury.

    • Social Impact

      Creating positive impact in our communities through increasing equity, access, and opportunity.

    1. Home
    2. Who We Are
    3. Media
    4. Fourth Circuit affirms district court order granting motion to dismiss, recognizing that action against sovereign Dutch entities cannot go forwardMedia

    Fourth Circuit affirms district court order granting motion to dismiss, recognizing that action against sovereign Dutch entities cannot go forward

    Feb 3, 2022

    Share

    Richmond, VA. A unanimous panel of judges for the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit affirmed the district court’s order dismissing a lawsuit challenging the ownership and display of more than 140 artworks by Dutch “Old Masters” owned by the Kingdom of the Netherlands, some of which were displayed by museums located in the Netherlands.

    In a case-resolving published opinion, the appellate court rejected the plaintiff’s appeal of the district court’s order granting the defendants’ joint motion to dismiss claims against (i) the Dutch Ministry of Education, Culture & Science and its cultural heritage agency (represented by Baker & Miller PLLC of Washington, DC) and (ii) four Dutch museums (represented by Nixon Peabody LLP). Womble Bond Dickinson was local counsel and participated in both the underlying action and the appeal.

    The dispute arose out of events that occurred early in World War II. The artworks came into ownership by the Netherlands as part of the country’s national collection in 1951, after having been previously returned to it by occupying authorities in post-war Germany. In late 2018, the plaintiff filed a lawsuit in the U.S. District Court of South Carolina asserting ownership as a descendant of an alleged wartime owner of the paintings. Most of the plaintiff’s claims were previously considered and denied by the Dutch Minister of Education, Culture & Science, based on the detailed published recommendation of the Dutch Restitution Committee, an independent advisory body.

    On March 6, 2020, following oral argument, U.S. District Judge Bruce Howe Hendricks issued an order granting the joint motion to dismiss filed in Berg v. The Kingdom of the Netherlands, et al. (D.S.C. No. 18-cv-3123-BHH). The court determined that it lacked subject matter jurisdiction over the Kingdom, the Ministry, and its agency, as no exception to the Foreign Sovereign Immunities Act (the FSIA) applied to permit a court to take jurisdiction over these sovereign defendants. The court also recognized that venue was improper in South Carolina and additionally held that dismissal was appropriate on the grounds of the plaintiff’s lack of standing and a lack of personal jurisdiction over the museums. The plaintiff appealed, challenging three grounds for dismissal against the Ministry, the agency, and four public museums; he did not appeal dismissal of the Kingdom or the private museums, nor the district court’s venue determination.

    On February 3, 2022, following an October 2021 oral argument before the panel, the Fourth Circuit affirmed the district court’s decision. Specifically, the court affirmed the district court’s finding that the Ministry and the agency, like the Kingdom of the Netherlands, was entitled to sovereign immunity. The court also agreed that venue was improper in South Carolina, noting that the plaintiff failed to challenge this finding on appeal. Finding dismissal was warranted on these two grounds, the Fourth Circuit did not address the plaintiff’s standing and personal jurisdiction challenges.

    “We are pleased that the Fourth Circuit endorsed the district court’s well-reasoned and thorough analysis of why the claims cannot move forward,” said Sarah Erickson André, Nixon Peabody appellate partner and a member of the firm’s Arts & Cultural Institutions team. In addition to Ms. André, the Nixon Peabody team consisted of Thaddeus J. Stauber, head of the firm’s Arts & Cultural Institutions team, and Nixon Peabody alumna Kristin M. Jamberdino.

    Co-counsels were Donald I. Baker and Lucy S. Clippinger of the international law group at Baker & Miller PLLC and Samuel Hartzell, Brent Powell, and James Myrick of Womble Bond Dickinson (US) LLP.

    Practices

    Litigation

    Industries

    Arts & Cultural Institutions

    Professionals in the Practice Area

    View All
    • Anthony Barron

      Partner / Chair, Litigation Department
      • San Francisco
      • Office:415.984.8309
      • abarron@nixonpeabody.com
      Anthony Barron
    • Kimberly Harding

      Partner / Deputy Leader, Litigation Department
      Leader, Labor Relations Team
      • Rochester
      • Office:585.263.1037
      • kharding@nixonpeabody.com
      Kimberly Harding
    • John Ruskusky

      Partner / Practice Group Leader, Complex Disputes / Leader, Medical Device, Pharmaceuticals and Diagnostic Health
      • Chicago
      • Office:312.977.4460
        Mobile:708.606.8720
      • jtruskusky@nixonpeabody.com
      John Ruskusky
    • Jeffrey S. Brenner

      Partner / Practice Group Leader, Construction & Real Estate Litigation
      • Providence
      • Office:401.454.1042
      • jbrenner@nixonpeabody.com
      Jeffrey S. Brenner
    • Daniel J. Hurteau

      Partner / Deputy Practice Group Leader, Complex Disputes
      • Albany
      • Office:518.427.2652
      • dhurteau@nixonpeabody.com
      Daniel J. Hurteau
    View All

    Insights And Happenings

    • Press Release

      Nixon Peabody represents the Whitney Museum of American Art in transformational art world transaction

      Feb 23, 2022
    • Press Release

      U.S. Supreme Court to consider proper choice-of-law test in action involving a foreign sovereign entity

      Sep 30, 2021
    • Press Release

      Los Angeles Business Journal names Nixon Peabody’s Thaddeus Stauber as a “Leader of Influence”

      July 12, 2021

    Subscribe to stay informed of the latest legal news, alerts, and business trends.Subscribe

    • People
    • Capabilities
    • Insights
    • About
    • Locations
    • Events
    • Careers
    • Alumni
    • © 2023 Nixon Peabody. All rights reserved
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms of Use
    • Statement of Client Rights
    • Supplier Diversity Program
    • Nixon Peabody International LLC
    • PAL