Skip to main content

Nixon Peabody LLP

  • People
  • Capabilities
  • Insights
  • About
Trending Topics
    • People
    • Capabilities
    • Insights
    • About
    • Locations
    • Events
    • Careers
    • Alumni
    Practices

    View All

    • Affordable Housing
    • Community Development Finance
    • Corporate & Finance
    • Cybersecurity & Privacy
    • Entertainment & Media
    • Environmental
    • Franchising & Distribution
    • Government Investigations & White Collar Defense
    • Healthcare
    • Intellectual Property
    • International Services
    • Labor, Employment, and Benefits
    • Litigation
    • Private Wealth & Advisory
    • Project Finance
    • Public Finance
    • Real Estate
    • Regulatory & Government Relations
    Industries

    View All

    • Aviation
    • Cannabis
    • Consumer
    • Energy
    • Financial Services
    • Healthcare
    • Higher Education
    • Infrastructure
    • Manufacturing
    • Nonprofit Organizations
    • Real Estate
    • Sports & Stadiums
    • Technology
    Value-Added Services

    View All

    • Alternative Fee Arrangements

      Developing innovative pricing structures and alternative fee agreement models that deliver additional value for our clients.

    • Continuing Education

      Advancing professional knowledge and offering credits for attorneys, staff and other professionals.

    • Crisis Advisory

      Helping clients respond correctly when a crisis occurs.

    • DEI Strategic Services

      Providing our clients with legal, strategic, and practical advice to make transformational changes in their organizations.

    • eDiscovery

      Leveraging law and technology to deliver sound solutions.

    • Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG)

      We help clients create positive return on investments in people, products, and the planet.

    • Global Services

      Delivering seamless service through partnerships across the globe.

    • Innovation

      Leveraging leading-edge technology to guide change and create seamless, collaborative experiences for clients and attorneys.

    • IPED

      Industry-leading conferences focused on affordable housing, tax credits, and more.

    • Legal Project Management

      Providing actionable information to support strategic decision-making.

    • Legally Green

      Teaming with clients to advance sustainable projects, mitigate the effects of climate change, and protect our planet.

    • Nixon Peabody Trust Company

      Offering a range of investment management and fiduciary services.

    • NP Capital Connector

      Bringing together companies and investors for tomorrow’s new deals.

    • NP Second Opinion

      Offering fresh insights on cases that are delayed, over budget, or off-target from the desired resolution.

    • NP Trial

      Courtroom-ready lawyers who can resolve disputes early on clients’ terms or prevail at trial before a judge or jury.

    • Social Impact

      Creating positive impact in our communities through increasing equity, access, and opportunity.

    • Women in Dealmaking

      We provide strategic counsel on complex corporate transactions and unite dynamic women in the dealmaking arena.

    1. Home
    2. Insights
    3. Alerts
    4. Fiduciary governance: Managing increasing health and welfare fiduciary risks

      Alerts

    Alert / Benefits

    Fiduciary governance: Managing increasing health and welfare fiduciary risks

    Sep 14, 2023

    LinkedInX (Twitter)EmailCopy URL

    By Damian Myers, Yelena Gray, Lena Gionnette and Annie Zhang

    Take action now to stave off the pending surge in class action litigation against health and welfare plan sponsors and fiduciaries.

    What’s the impact?

    • Plaintiffs’ firms are actively looking for potential employee plaintiffs who participate in group health plans.
    • In addition to civil litigation, the DOL has increased its investigation activity in the health plan arena.
    • Manage risks by establishing a health and welfare plan fiduciary committee to conduct formal, well-documented processes to monitor health plan activities and service provider performance and fees.

    DOWNLOAD

    PDF: Health and welfare fiduciary risks

    The Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974 (ERISA) sets forth several fiduciary obligations for those responsible for administering employee benefit plans. These fiduciary obligations apply to both retirement plans and health and welfare benefit plans. Employers that sponsor retirement plans are acutely aware of these fiduciary responsibilities—over the past 20 years, numerous class action lawsuits have alleged fiduciary breaches in connection with plan fees, expenses, and investment performance, among other issues. These lawsuits changed the retirement plan governance landscape. For example, as a current best practice, retirement plan fiduciaries form fiduciary committees that meet quarterly to evaluate investment performance and fees, service provider fees, and other fiduciary matters.

    Although the same fiduciary obligations driving retirement plan litigation also apply to health and welfare benefit plans, there has not been the same type of wide-ranging litigation against health and welfare plan fiduciaries (note there has been a plethora of class actions and settlements related to deficient COBRA election notices). As a result, health and welfare plan fiduciary governance tends to be less formal than in the retirement plan context.

    Unfortunately, storm clouds are rolling in for health and welfare plan fiduciaries as plaintiffs’ firms are actively looking for potential employee plaintiffs who have participated in group health plans. The following recent developments could serve as the foundation for future health and welfare plan fiduciary litigation:

    • In connection with recent mandates related to health plan price transparency, plan fiduciaries are required to publicly disclose discounted service costs. It will only be a matter of time before third-party services synthesize that information into a form plaintiffs’ attorneys can utilize to allege ERISA fiduciary breaches related to excessive plan fees and expenses.
    • Under the Consolidated Appropriations Act of 2021 (CAA), health and welfare plan brokers and consultants must disclose all direct and indirect compensation earned in connection with services provided to the plans. This requirement is derived from the same ERISA statute that has long mandated similar disclosures for retirement plans and fashioned after U.S. Department of Labor (DOL) regulations interpreting the statute in the retirement plan context. Fiduciaries who fail to collect or evaluate these disclosures could face liability.
    • Several state and federal agencies are currently investigating the business practices of third-party administrators, pharmacy benefit managers, and benefits consultants. To the extent that these investigations find that these entities have violated laws to the detriment of their clients (i.e., health plan fiduciaries), a natural next step would be for plaintiffs’ attorneys to assess whether plan fiduciaries failed to properly monitor their service providers.
    • Protection of individual health information has long been a requirement under the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act; however, as cybersecurity risks increase every year, so does the risk of fiduciary liability if plan fiduciaries do not take adequate measures to protect personal health information. The DOL has recently initiated cybersecurity audits, thus creating even more fiduciary risk.

    A few years ago, one could argue that these risks were mostly theoretical. That is no longer the case, as the same plaintiffs’ firms that pioneered the retirement plan litigation 20 years ago are now actively investigating employer-sponsored health plans.

    Additional concerns—DOL investigations of health and welfare plans

    Even before the passage of the CAA and enactment of the transparency in coverage regulations, the DOL initiated examinations of welfare benefit plans (particularly group health plans). With recent changes in the statutory and regulatory landscape, the DOL has increased its investigation activity in the health plan arena. Investigations can originate for a variety of reasons, including from participant complaints or at random. Regardless of the trigger, the DOL of late has focused its efforts on compliance with various aspects of ERISA, emphasizing the fiduciary role plan sponsors play in administering a plan, monitoring vendors, and ensuring proper handling of participant claims for benefits. In addition, during recent investigations, the DOL has focused on certain enforcement priorities, such as compliance with the Affordable Care Act coverage mandates (e.g., preventive care and emergency services) and mental health parity requirements.

    Looking ahead—mitigate fiduciary risk

    So, what can plan fiduciaries do to mitigate the growing risks? As with the fiduciary risks in the retirement plan context, the best defensive front against health plan fiduciary liability is a formal, well-documented process to monitor health plan activities and service provider performance and fees. For those employers or plan sponsors that have not done so already, now is the time to either create a separate health and welfare plan fiduciary committee or direct the existing retirement plan fiduciary committee to cover health and welfare plan matters.

    To establish a health and welfare plan fiduciary committee, plan fiduciaries should work with counsel to create a charter (or expand an existing charter) to set forth the responsibilities of the committee. These responsibilities could include:

    • Collecting and evaluating broker/consultant fee disclosures;
    • Monitoring medical plan service providers, including performance guarantee assessments;
    • Conducting and evaluating the results of independent claims audits and contract compliance reviews;
    • Monitoring pharmacy benefit managers and related service providers, including performance guarantee assessments, discount and minimum rebate guarantee reconciliation, independent claims audits, and contract compliance reviews;
    • Conducting periodic requests for proposals to ensure that the scope of services, fees, network discounts, and pharmacy benefit manager pricing remain competitive;
    • Monitoring compliance with law and directing service providers to make adjustments as needed;
    • Managing government investigations;
    • Addressing other miscellaneous matters, such as producing participant communications, handling participant or healthcare provider disputes, and managing health plan litigation.

    As with retirement plan committees, health and welfare plan fiduciary committees will most likely need to hire subject matter experts—benefits counsel, independent benefit consultants, and auditors—to assist with fiduciary governance. Most importantly, these committees should maintain written records of all committee activities. These written records are the first line of defense against fiduciary litigation.

    Stay tuned

    This Client Alert is the first of a series that Nixon Peabody’s Employee Benefits & ERISA team will release over the next two months. This alert series will provide a deeper dive into health and welfare plan fiduciary best practices, touching on medical and pharmacy service provider evaluation and monitoring, cybersecurity risks, management of participant claims and provider disputes, and fiduciary compliance reviews.

    Practices

    Employee Benefits & ERISA

    Insights And Happenings

    • Alert

      Bringing it all together — Health and welfare plan fiduciary compliance reviews

      Nov 17, 2023
    • Alert

      Fiduciary governance: Handling participant claims and appeals and provider disputes

      Nov 6, 2023
    • Alert

      Fiduciary governance: HIPAA and cybersecurity best practices

      Oct 20, 2023
    The foregoing has been prepared for the general information of clients and friends of the firm. It is not meant to provide legal advice with respect to any specific matter and should not be acted upon without professional counsel. If you have any questions or require any further information regarding these or other related matters, please contact your regular Nixon Peabody LLP representative. This material may be considered advertising under certain rules of professional conduct.

    Subscribe to stay informed of the latest legal news, alerts, and business trends.Subscribe

    • People
    • Capabilities
    • Insights
    • About
    • Locations
    • Events
    • Careers
    • Alumni
    • Cookie Preferences
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms of Use
    • Accessibility Statement
    • Statement of Client Rights
    • Purchase Order Terms & Conditions
    • Nixon Peabody International LLC
    • PAL
    © 2025 Nixon Peabody. All rights reserved