On November 16, the US District Court for the District of Massachusetts granted summary judgment to a coalition of higher education and labor organizations and vacated in its entirety the Department of Homeland Security’s (DHS Final Rule that would have replaced “duration of status” with fixed admission periods for F, J, and I nonimmigrants.
The longstanding duration-of-status framework remains in effect. Colleges and universities nationwide may continue to admit, enroll, and advise F-1 students and J-1 exchange visitors under the regulations and procedures that applied before the Final Rule, regardless of whether they were plaintiffs in Presidents’ Alliance on Higher Education and Immigration v. US Department of Homeland Security, No. 1:26-cv-13799-FDS (D. Mass.).
However, the decision remains subject to appellate review, leaving a question open about whether colleges and universities have secured a lasting victory or merely won this round.
Background
On July 17, DHS published a Final Rule titled “Establishing a Fixed Time Period of Admission and an Extension of Stay Procedure for Nonimmigrant Academic Students, Exchange Visitors, and Representatives of Foreign Information Media,” 91 Fed. Reg. 44976. The rule was scheduled to take effect on September 15. Among other things, it would have:
- Replaced duration-of-status admission with fixed admission periods tied to the length of a student’s or exchange visitor’s program, generally subject to a four-year maximum ;
- Required F-1 students and J-1 exchange visitors who needed additional time to seek an extension of stay through US Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS), with approval left to the agency’s discretion and generally without an administrative appeal ;
- Restricted academic mobility for F-1 students , prohibit ing graduate-level students from changing educational objectives and, generally, transferring institutions during their programs, subject to limited exceptions, and preventing students from beginning a new program at the same or a lower academic level than a previously completed program ;
- Reduced the F-1 post-completion grace period from 60 days to 30 days ; and
- Limited most I nonimmigrants (foreign information media representatives) to admission periods of no more than 240 days, with a shorter period for certain individuals holding passports issued by the People’s Republic of China.
The coalition of higher education and labor organizations that challenged the rule included the Presidents’ Alliance, NAFSA: Association of International Educators, the Association of Independent Colleges and Universities in Massachusetts, the American Federation of Teachers, and several other labor organizations.
On September 14, Judge F. Dennis Saylor IV issued a preliminary injunction postponing the rule’s effective date under Section 705 of the Administrative Procedure Act (APA). The court concluded that the plaintiffs were likely to succeed in their claim that the rule was arbitrary and capricious. Preliminary relief prevented DHS from implementing the rule while the litigation proceeded, leaving the existing regulatory framework in place nationwide.
The government appealed the preliminary injunction to the US Court of Appeals for the First Circuit. The parties subsequently returned to the district court on cross-motions for summary judgment.
The court’s decision
On November 16, the court granted the plaintiffs’ motion for summary judgment and denied the government’s cross-motion. It concluded that the Final Rule was unlawful on two independent grounds: it was arbitrary and capricious under the APA, and its restrictions on F-1 academic mobility exceeded DHS’s statutory authority.
The rule was arbitrary and capricious
The court adopted its earlier analysis from the preliminary injunction decision, concluding that DHS failed to satisfy several fundamental APA requirements. Specifically, DHS failed to:
- Conduct a reasoned assessment of the rule’s costs and benefits ;
- Establish a rational connection between the rule and its stated objectives of preventing fraud and protecting national security ;
- Meaningfully consider less burdensome alternatives that could address the agency’s concerns; and
- Provide adequate responses to significant public comments raising substantial concerns about the rule’s effects and implementation.
The court was particularly critical of DHS’s reliance on fraud and national security concerns to justify replacing a longstanding system with fixed admission periods and discretionary extensions. It found that DHS had not adequately explained how requiring an immigration-status review after four years would prevent the types of misconduct it identified, or why the proposed system was preferable to less disruptive alternatives.
DHS failed to account for existing SEVIS tools
The November 16 decision also addressed a specific deficiency in DHS’s consideration of alternatives: its failure to evaluate whether enhanced use of SEVIS could address the agency’s stated concerns.
The court noted that schools participating in the F-1 and J-1 programs already operate under extensive reporting and recordkeeping obligations. Designated school officials (DSOs) and responsible officers (ROs) must provide accurate, complete, and timely information about students and exchange visitors, including changes in academic status and program participation. Schools and program sponsors risk losing their certification or designation if they fail to meet those requirements.
The court also identified several ways DHS already uses SEVIS information to detect potential fraud and abuse. Those efforts include prosecuting “pay-to-stay” schemes, reviewing SEVIS records for potential violations, and running the names of more than one million students through the National Crime Information Center.
DHS argued that SEVIS is a school reporting system, not an immigration-status adjudication system. The court found that explanation insufficient. DHS had not adequately explained how an unreviewable, discretionary renewal process after four years would meaningfully improve fraud detection, or why its benefits would outweigh the substantial costs of abandoning the existing framework.
At a minimum, the court concluded that DHS should have evaluated the costs and benefits of enhancing SEVIS against those of the Final Rule. Its failure to do so provided further support for the conclusion that the rule was arbitrary and capricious.
The rule exceeded DHS’s statutory authority
The court also resolved a question it had reserved at the preliminary injunction stage: whether the Final Rule’s restrictions on academic mobility were consistent with the F-1 statute, 8 U.S.C. § 1101(a)(15)(F).
That statute defines the F-1 classification to include bona fide students who are qualified to pursue a full course of study and seek to enter the United States temporarily for that purpose. DHS argued that its regulatory authority permitted it to define the types of academic programs that could qualify as an appropriate “course of study.”
The court rejected that interpretation. Relying on Washington Alliance of Technology Workers v. US Department of Homeland Security, 50 F.4th 164 (D.C. Cir. 2022), the court explained that although Congress delegated authority to DHS to regulate the time and conditions of nonimmigrants’ stay, those requirements must be reasonably related to the nature and purpose of the F-1 visa classification.
The court concluded that the Final Rule’s academic restrictions did not meet that standard. Among other things, the rule would have effectively restricted students from:
- Completing extended programs of study, including PhD programs;
- Pursuing joint graduate degrees;
- Changing their academic concentrations; and
- Pursuing a second degree at the same or a lower academic level, including an MBA after completing a JD
The court emphasized that the F-1 program exists to permit and encourage foreign students to pursue educational opportunities in the United States. Restrictions that prevent bona fide students from pursuing legitimate academic programs are not reasonably related to that purpose.
The court vacated the entire Final Rule
Finally, the court rejected DHS’s request to remand the rule to the agency without vacating it. The court explained that vacatur is the standard remedy under the APA and that there was no basis to depart from that remedy here. The existing regulatory framework had been in place for decades, and the Final Rule had never taken effect.
Accordingly, the court vacated the Final Rule in its entirety under 5 U.S.C. § 706.
What this means for your institution
- Continue operating under duration of status. The existing regulatory framework remains in effect for F-1 students and J-1 exchange visitors. Institutions may continue to admit, enroll, and advise students and scholars under the rules and procedures that applied before the Final Rule. The new fixed admission periods and USCIS extension-of-stay process do not apply.
- Academic pathways remain available. Institutions may continue to support PhD timelines, joint and dual degrees, changes in academic concentration, transfers, and additional degrees at the same or a lower academic level under existing regulations. These options remain subject to applicable F-1 eligibility, program requirements, and SEVIS reporting obligations; the decision does not eliminate those requirements.
- Maintenance of status. Despite this decision, DHS has signal ed an increased focus on maintenance of status, and we expect to see that continue in adjudications of change of status cases for students seeking to transition to other nonimmigrant and immigrant visa statuses, including H-1B. Institutions should remind students of the obligations and requirements of their statuses and the potential for violations to impact their future status options.
- Maintain existing SEVIS compliance. The court’s discussion of SEVIS reinforces the importance of the reporting and recordkeeping obligations already imposed on schools and exchange visitor sponsors. Accurate and timely reporting remains essential to maintaining institutional certification and program designation. The decision does not reduce those obligations; it underscores that DHS failed to adequately consider the existing system and potential enhancements to it as alternatives to the Final Rule.
- Communicate the changes carefully. Institutions should ensure that international student and scholar offices, admissions personnel, academic leadership, faculty hosts, and affected students understand that the Final Rule has been vacated and that the preexisting duration-of-status framework remains controlling.
Looking ahead
On November 13, the First Circuit placed the government’s appeal of the September 14 preliminary injunction in abeyance for 30 days, while the district court resolved the merits. That appeal may now become moot because the preliminary injunction has been superseded by the final judgment. DHS may separately appeal the November 16 decision and seek a stay. An appeal alone would not automatically reinstate the vacated rule.
Nonetheless, the court’s application of the “reasonably related” standard from Washington Alliance may have implications beyond the duration-of-status rule. In particular, its analysis may inform future challenges to DHS restrictions affecting F-1 students’ academic and practical training opportunities, including the separately pending challenge to the now-enjoined Curricular Practical Training (CPT) broadcast messages.
The merits of the CPT litigation present distinct legal questions, including whether DHS may impose new eligibility requirements through agency guidance without notice-and-comment rulemaking and whether its interpretation is consistent with the existing CPT regulation. The November 16 decision does not resolve those questions, but its discussion of the statutory purpose of the F-1 classification may provide useful context as the court considers DHS’s authority to restrict students’ educational and practical-training opportunities.

