On November 17, the Department of Labor (DOL) issued a Notice of Proposed Rulemaking (NPRM or “proposed rule”), “Modernizing the Labor Market Test and Improving Protections for US Workers in the PERM Immigrant Visa Program,” which will modify the existing Program Electronic Review Management (PERM) labor certification process. While only a proposed rule at this time, the proposed changes will mark the first major revision to the PERM labor certification process in over twenty years and will make it much more difficult for employers to successfully sponsor key foreign national employees for immigrant visas.
At a high level, the proposed changes would:
- Require employers to attempt to recruit US workers consistent with current hiring and recruitment practices, including the use of social media and employer website postings normally used by the employer;
- Require employers to recruit for a longer period of time;
- Prohibit the filing of a PERM labor certification if there has been a qualifying layoff in the prior two years and create a continuing obligation to report a qualifying layoff through I-140 Immigrant Visa Petition adjudication; and
- Give employers a shorter window to file PERM labor certification applications, among other changes discussed below.
Background
The Immigration and Nationality Act (INA) prohibits the admission of employment-based immigrants to perform skilled or unskilled labor in the US as lawful permanent residents unless DOL has certified (1) there are not sufficient US workers who are able, willing, qualified, and available to perform such skilled or unskilled labor; and (2) the employment of the sponsored foreign national worker will not adversely affect the wages and working conditions of similarly employed US workers. How a US employer obtains this certification for foreign national workers is known as the permanent labor certification process.
The last major change to the permanent labor certification process occurred in March 2005 with the introduction of the PERM labor certification process, which streamlined the previous labor certification process and, in short, required employers to first obtain a Prevailing Wage Determination (PWD) for the job opportunity, conduct a good faith test of the domestic labor market via pre-defined recruitment steps to determine the availability of qualified and willing US workers, and provide notice to current employees. Except for minor changes introduced in 2007, the PERM process has remained unchanged since 2005.
In addition, DOL maintains a list of occupations, known as Schedule A, that have been designated as in short supply of qualified US workers, and which permit employers to bypass the required labor certification. For college and university teachers, employers have the option of using a streamlined process, known as Special Handling.
Key changes to the PERM labor certification process
Elimination of Schedule A
The proposed rule would eliminate Schedule A, meaning occupations previously designated as being in short supply of qualified US workers, including nurses and physical therapists, would be subject to the PERM labor certification process. This would dramatically increase the costs and timeframes for US healthcare organizations reliant on foreign nationals to adequately staff their operations.
Changes to filing timelines
The proposed rule would also require filing of the Application for Permanent Employment Certification within 30 calendar days after the employer has completed all pre-filing recruitment requirements. Under current regulations, employers must file the application within 180 days of beginning pre-filing recruitment. College and university teachers or professional athletes and coaches currently must do so within 18 months of the foreign national’s selection.
New rules regarding layoffs of US workers
Under current regulations, an employer must notify and consider for the job opportunity any US worker it laid off in the six months before filing the application, if the workers held a position in the same or related occupation and in the same geographical area of intended employment. Under the proposed rule, employers would have to attest that they had no layoffs involving a same or similar occupation in the area of intended employment during the two years prior to filing the application. They would also have to report qualifying layoffs that occur after filing and until the I-140 petition is approved. Based on current processing times, that reporting obligation could last several years.
Changes to the notice requirement
Under the proposed rule, the required Notice of Filing would need to be posted 10 business days before the filing for PERM labor certification and remain posted through the date the I-140 is approved.
Revision to recruitment methods and timeframes
As proposed, employers would be required to use more modern recruitment methods that align with their usual recruitment practices. Employers would no longer be required to place an advertisement in two consecutive Sunday newspapers but would still be required to place a job order with the State Workforce Agency (SWA). While the SWA job order is active, an employer would be required to advertise via a job fair, on-campus recruiting event, and/or college, university or trade school placement office (or through as many of these methods as normally used by the employer for non-PERM recruitment). In addition, an employer would be required to recruit via its website and a separate job search website. The proposed rule contemplates the use of social media platform(s) if customarily used by the employer for non-PERM recruitment.
The minimum recruitment period would increase under the proposed rule from 30 days to either 90 days or the length of time an employer normally advertised for non-PERM job opportunities in the same occupational classification during the most recent 12 months, whichever is longer. For example, if an employer normally advertises for 120 days, the PERM advertising must be for 120 days, so that PERM recruitment is conducted in a manner that is the same as the employer uses for non-PERM recruitment for same or substantially comparable positions.
Revisions to filing process
Unlike the current process, where only the Application for Permanent Employment Certification is submitted, and supporting documentation—such as recruitment report, Notice of Filing, documentation of recruitment, and résumés and/or applications of US workers—is requested later if audited by DOL, the proposed rule would require an employer to submit both the application and supporting documents at the time of filing, effectively auditing every application.
In addition, the proposed rule would amend long-standing rules for conducting recruitment from company headquarters for remote, teleworking, and roving work arrangements. It also contemplates and seeks comments on elimination of fully remote work from PERM labor certification eligibility.
Relevance to higher education
The proposed rule would retain the current alternative recruitment procedures available to colleges and universities known as Special Handling, allowing them to utilize their standard competitive recruitment process for faculty instead of the PERM labor certification recruitment.
However, as with the proposed change for all employers, a college or university would need to submit their recruitment report and all evidence of compliance with advertising requirements and consideration of US workers—including their résumés and applications—when filing their application. Current regulations give employers 18 months after selecting a foreign national college or university teacher through a competitive recruitment process to submit an application. The proposed rule would shorten that submission deadline to 30 days.
Proposed implementation timeframe
The proposed rule has a 60-day comment period, meaning all comments must be received no later than January 19, 2027. While there is no established timeline for this, DOL will likely take at least 60 days to consider all submitted comments. Once finalized, the proposed rule provides a 90-day transition period after publication of the final rule, meaning PERM labor certifications submitted on or after the 90-day transition period would need to comply with the new requirements.


